BREAKDOWN · WALMART (WMT) VS. TARGET (TGT)
Walmart vs. Target before earnings: why Walmart still costs twice as much per sales dollar
Target has been the faster stock. Over the year through November 11, its total return was 86.06%, versus 22.51% for Walmart and 12.44% for the S&P 500 ETF (SPY). Target closed at $162.70, 3.55% below its August 24 closing high, and Walmart closed at $125.67.1
The rally has not closed the valuation gap. At the November 11 close, investors paid 1.36 times trailing sales for Walmart and 0.69 times for Target, so a dollar of Walmart revenue cost about twice as much. On GAAP earnings the gap is wider: 45.53 times trailing diluted EPS for Walmart and 16.88 times for Target.231 Walmart’s premium is not explained by higher margins, because Target kept more of each sales dollar as operating profit and as free cash flow.
The earnings calendar lists Target before the open on November 18 and Walmart before the open on November 19. Reporting dates can change.4 The reports arrive after a quarter in which both received tariff refunds and handled them very differently, which shapes how each set of results should be read.56
| Metric | Walmart (WMT) | Target (TGT) |
|---|---|---|
| Price to trailing 12-month sales, Nov. 11 close | 1.36x | 0.69x |
| Trailing P/E, GAAP diluted, Nov. 11 close | 45.53 | 16.88 |
| Trailing 12-month GAAP operating margin | 4.39% | 5.59% |
| Trailing 12-month free cash flow margin (operating cash flow less capital spending) | 1.84% | 4.14% |
| Latest quarter revenue growth from a year ago | +5.9% | +5.3% |
| Latest quarter comparable sales | +2.6% (Walmart U.S.) | +3.8% |
| One-year stock return to Nov. 11 | +22.51% | +86.06% |
Walmart’s trailing figures run through July 31, 2026, and Target’s through August 1, 2026. Free cash flow is a Bullish Gator calculation using each company’s latest annual report and 10-Q.231
What the premium is not paying for
Over their latest four reported quarters, Target’s gross margin was 29.3% and Walmart’s 25.2%. Target’s GAAP operating margin was 5.59% and Walmart’s 4.39%.23 Target’s figure includes a one-time tariff refund described below; without it, Target’s trailing operating margin would have been about 4.67%, still above Walmart’s.53
Cash tells the same story in percentage terms. Operating cash flow was 8.1% of Target’s trailing revenue and 5.8% of Walmart’s, while both spent about 4% of sales on property and equipment. That left free cash flow of about $4.5 billion for Target, or 4.14% of revenue, and about $13.5 billion for Walmart, or 1.84%.23 Walmart guides capital spending to about 4.0% of net sales this fiscal year, up from an original plan of about 3.5%.7
Current margins therefore do not explain Walmart’s higher multiple. The clearest business support for the premium is Walmart’s scale, steadier growth and faster-growing e-commerce, advertising and membership operations.
Where the premium comes from
Scale is the starting point. Walmart generated about $735.8 billion of trailing revenue, roughly 6.8 times Target’s $107.7 billion. Using the November 11 closes and each company’s latest disclosed shares outstanding, their approximate market values were $997 billion for Walmart and $73.9 billion for Target.123 Walmart’s growth record is also steadier: annual revenue grew about 5.3% a year over its last three fiscal years, while Target’s shrank about 1.3% a year.8
The faster-growing parts of Walmart are the ones investors tend to value most. In the quarter ended July 31, Walmart said global e-commerce sales rose 23%, its global advertising business grew 38% and membership fee revenue rose 17%. Walmart U.S. comparable sales rose 2.6%, led by a 1.5% rise in transactions, and the company said comparable sales absorbed a headwind from pharmacy deflation tied to new drug-price rules. Sam’s Club transactions rose 7.0%, and international net sales grew 12.8%, or 7.9% in constant currency.6
Walmart’s guidance points to profit growing faster than sales. After the quarter, it raised its fiscal 2027 outlook to net sales growth of 4.0% to 5.0% and adjusted operating income growth of 7.0% to 8.5%, both in constant currency, with adjusted EPS of $2.80 to $2.87.7 It also returned more cash through buybacks, about $7.0 billion over the latest four quarters against about $153 million at Target.23
Same refund, different choices
Both retailers received tariff refunds in their latest quarter. Target recognized $994 million of refunds of tariffs imposed under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act as a reduction of cost of sales. The refund added 3.7 percentage points to its quarterly gross margin and $1.65 to EPS, which reached $4.11 against $2.05 a year earlier. Without the refund, Target said, EPS rose 20%.5
By our calculation, the refund lifted Target’s quarterly operating margin to 9.65% from 5.22% a year earlier; without it, the margin would have been about 5.90%.35 Target kept the benefit in its outlook: full-year EPS of $9.90 to $10.90 includes about $1.65 from refunds, and its full-year operating margin of around 6% includes about 90 basis points from them.5
Walmart booked refunds too, but partly offset them with price cuts in the same quarter, and said it is prioritizing the remaining refunds into price investments in the second half. That helps explain why its third-quarter guidance calls for adjusted operating income growth of only 2.0% to 4.0%. Chief Financial Officer John David Rainey asked investors to consider the second and third quarters together to judge the business.67 The choice matters for valuation, too. Removing the $1.65 refund from Target’s trailing EPS raises its P/E to about 20.4 from 16.88, which narrows the gap to Walmart’s 45.53 but leaves Walmart more than twice as expensive.51
Can Target keep closing the gap?
Target’s latest quarter gives its bulls real evidence. Comparable sales rose 3.8%, driven by a 3.6% increase in traffic, with store comparable sales up 2.7% and digital comparable sales up 8.7%, led by more than 25% growth in same-day delivery. Non-merchandise sales, including Roundel advertising, Target Circle 360 membership and the Target+ marketplace, grew more than 20%, and Target said net sales grew in all six core merchandise categories.5 “Over the past year, we’ve reduced prices on more than 10,000 frequently purchased items,” Chief Executive Officer Michael Fiddelke said.5
The caution is in the comparisons. Target said its gross margin, excluding refunds, expanded about one percentage point partly because it was lapping last year’s elevated markdowns and purchase order cancellation costs, and its selling, general and administrative expense rate rose to 21.6% from 21.3%.5 Its guidance for the year, excluding refunds, implies an operating margin about half a point above last year’s adjusted 4.6%.5
Walmart fell after each of its two most recent reports: 9.15% after its August 20 beat and 7.27% after its May 21 tie. Target rose 4.28% after its August 19 beat.9 Both stocks remain near recent highs, raising the bar for next week.1
What the coverage is saying
Financial media has framed the same question this comparison asks. The Motley Fool, writing on November 9, put Walmart at 45.2 times trailing earnings and Target at 17.1, and said the gap was wider on price to free cash flow, at 73.3 against 16.8. It added that both multiples need a caveat for tariff refunds, and that Walmart received roughly $2.9 billion of its own, much of which it is putting into lower prices by expanding its rollback program from 7,200 to 11,000 items.10
The case for Walmart in that coverage centers on its newer businesses. The same Motley Fool article described Walmart as “acting like a tech company that just happens to sell bananas,” noting CFO John David Rainey’s comment that almost half of last quarter’s profit growth came from membership, advertising and marketplace, and that automated facilities now handle more than half of its e-commerce fulfillment volume.10 Kalkine Media reported that Bank of America raised its Walmart price target on November 11, arguing Walmart can keep taking share in grocery and general merchandise but needs faster U.S. comparable revenue outside health and wellness, plus proof that marketplace and advertising can speed up earnings growth.1112 An October 16 market roundup also reported a Deutsche Bank upgrade.13
The case for Target leans on its recovery. Mizuho analyst David Bellinger discussed Target’s momentum against Costco and Walmart on BNN Bloomberg in September, and in August, Sarah Henry described its turnaround as being in its early days, driven by inventory and AI-fueled digital growth.1415 The Motley Fool noted that traffic to Target from AI platforms such as Google Gemini and ChatGPT is growing at 3.5 times the industry rate, though from a small base.10 Simply Wall St argued that Target’s sharp one-year rally had shifted the question from whether the recovery was real to whether expected cash flows justify the current price.16
The caution runs mostly toward Walmart’s valuation. In a separate November 10 article, The Motley Fool said Walmart is “crushing it” on market-share gains, but that at 46 times forward earnings, “any sort of hiccup or slip-up” with its next results could trigger a sell-off.17 Simply Wall St said Walmart’s expanded $6 billion automation rollout with Symbotic may support future margins, while its valuation already looks rich against peers after a 182.7% five-year return.18 The Motley Fool also called Target’s 20% underlying earnings growth “a bit of a gimme” against last year’s weak quarter, and in August, LikeFolio’s consumer-demand data showed Walmart demand up about 14% from a year earlier but trailing Target and Costco.1019 These are the publishers’ and analysts’ views, not forecasts from Bullish Gator.
Earnings history
Since 2014, Walmart has posted 34 clear beats, five ties and six misses in 45 reports with an estimate, and Target 36 clear beats, two ties and 12 misses in 50.9 The moves below start at the close before each report, so they include the first jump or drop. They describe the past and carry no forecast.
| Measure | Walmart (WMT) | Target (TGT) |
|---|---|---|
| Reports with an estimate, since 2014 | 45 | 50 |
| Clear beats | 34 | 36 |
| Ties | 5 | 2 |
| Misses | 6 | 12 |
| Median EPS surprise | +4.35% | +6.48% |
| Median next-day move after clear beats | +1.66% | +2.46% |
| Latest report and next-day move | Aug. 20: beat, -9.15% | Aug. 19: beat, +4.28% |
The figures come from the Post-Earnings Intelligence, Event Rally & Return Estimator (PIERRE), which compares validated historical earnings results, EPS surprises and post-report price moves. A tie means the consensus estimate rounds to the reported EPS at two decimals.9
The longer view
Target’s rally has recovered only part of its earlier slump. If you had invested $10,000 in Walmart at the November 7, 2023 close, with dividends reinvested, it would have grown to about $23,464 by the November 10, 2026 close, the latest date in the calculator’s data. The same amount in Target would have grown to about $16,343. Use our Historical Stock Return Calculator to test another ticker, start date or investment amount.20
Where the comparison stands
On reported numbers, Target is the more profitable retailer per sales dollar and the cheaper stock by a wide margin, and its traffic is growing again. Walmart is larger, has the steadier growth record and is growing e-commerce, advertising and membership faster. Those differences help support its higher multiple, even though they do not eliminate the valuation gap. The refunds blur both pictures: they flatter Target’s trailing earnings and depress Walmart’s near-term profit growth by design.65
Next week’s reports will test each side. For Target, the questions are whether traffic-led comparable sales hold once last year’s weak comparisons pass and how margins look without refunds. For Walmart, they are whether sales land within its 3.0% to 3.75% third-quarter range, which Walmart said carries more than a percentage point of headwind from the timing of Flipkart’s Big Billion Days sale, and how much of its refund goes into prices.75
Our ratings
At the November 11 post-close update, both stocks rated Bullish overall. These are high-level composite labels; the comparison above rests on company filings and market prices.21
| Rating | Walmart (WMT) | Target (TGT) |
|---|---|---|
| Overall | Bullish | Bullish |
| Fundamental | Bullish | Neutral |
| Technical | Neutral | Bullish |
| Sentiment | Neutral | Neutral |
Sources & methodology
Sources
- Tiingo. End-of-day prices for WMT, TGT and SPY. Closes through November 11, 2026; one-year and 52-week figures use split- and dividend-adjusted closes.
- Walmart Inc. Form 10-Q for the quarter ended July 31, 2026 and Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended January 31, 2026. Revenue, cost of sales, operating income, cash flow, capital spending, buybacks, inventory and shares outstanding used in trailing figures and market value.
- Target Corporation. Form 10-Q for the quarter ended August 1, 2026 and Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended January 31, 2026. Net sales, cost of sales, operating income, cash flow, capital spending, buybacks, inventory and shares outstanding used in trailing figures and market value.
- API Ninjas. Earnings calendar. Projected reporting dates and before-market timing for Target and Walmart, checked November 12, 2026.
- Target Corporation. Target Corporation Reports Second Quarter Earnings, Exhibit 99 to the Form 8-K of August 19, 2026. Comparable sales, tariff refunds, margins, guidance and the CEO quotation.
- Walmart Inc. Walmart reports second quarter results, Exhibit 99.1 to the Form 8-K of August 20, 2026. Segment results, e-commerce, advertising, membership and tariff refunds.
- Walmart Inc. Q2 FY27 financial presentation, Exhibit 99.2 to the Form 8-K of August 20, 2026. Third-quarter and fiscal 2027 guidance and CFO commentary.
- Bullish Gator. Walmart and Target fundamental pages. Three-year revenue growth rates: Walmart $611.29 billion to $713.16 billion, Target $109.12 billion to $104.78 billion.
- Bullish Gator. Post-Earnings Intelligence, Event Rally & Return Estimator (PIERRE), retained Walmart and Target historical snapshot through August 2026 (snapshot cd22025b4d2e, captured November 12, 2026). Validated events with usable estimates since 2014; next-day moves start at the close before each report; descriptive history only.
- The Motley Fool. Target Trades at a Fraction of Walmart’s Valuation. Is the Discount Deserved? November 9, 2026. Commentary used as attributed context.
- Kalkine Media. Why Did BofA Lift Its Walmart (NASDAQ:WMT) Target? November 11, 2026.
- Bullish Gator video. Walmart PT Raised, Costco Special Dividend, Rigetti Earnings Miss: Wednesday Morning. November 11, 2026.
- Bullish Gator video. Morning Minute: TSMC Earnings, CoreWeave Selloff, Walmart Upgrade. October 16, 2026.
- Bullish Gator video. Why Target Is Gaining Ground vs. Costco and Walmart. BNN Bloomberg, September 24, 2026.
- Bullish Gator video. Target’s Turnaround Early Days; Walmart Earnings Preview: Sarah Henry. August 20, 2026.
- Simply Wall St. Target (TGT) Stock Looks Reasonable Against Its Cash Flow Outlook. November 10, 2026.
- The Motley Fool. How These 5 Big-Box Retailers Compete for the Same Shopper. November 10, 2026. Commentary used as attributed context.
- Simply Wall St. Walmart (WMT) Stock Looks About Right After Its $6 Billion Automation Push. November 12, 2026.
- Bullish Gator video. Target and Costco Outpacing Walmart in Demand: Watch for WMT Earnings Risk. August 20, 2026.
- Bullish Gator. Historical Stock Return Calculator. Split- and dividend-adjusted closes, dividends reinvested, November 7, 2023 to November 10, 2026, the latest date in the calculator data.
- Bullish Gator. WMT and TGT ratings snapshot, November 11, 2026 post-close (research snapshot 20261112T040002Z, file hash 4e2f32c7f38e). Internal retained snapshot containing the Overall, Fundamental, Technical and Sentiment labels used in this article. Current stock pages may show newer readings and are not the historical source.